Charities win appeal over the amount awarded to estranged daughter in her mother's will

17th March 2017 Commercial

The Supreme Court recently made its decision in the eagerly-anticipated case of Ilott v Mitson.

In absence of making a provision for her daughter in her will, Mrs Jackson left most of her estate to a number of charities. In the original court decision, the district judge held that, despite being estranged from her mother for most of the 26 years before she died, the will did not make reasonable financial provision for Mrs llott and she was subsequently awarded £50,000. The amount was essentially tripled on appeal and Mrs Ilott was awarded £143,000 to buy a house and £20,000 in instalments by the Court of Appeal.

The charities listed as beneficiaries challenged this increase, stating that people should be able to choose who actually benefits from their will. The Supreme Court unanimously allowed the charities' appeal and held that Mrs Ilott would only receive the original £50,000 awarded by the district judge.

The key principle arising from this judgment is that when a child makes a claim against a parent's estate, any provision is limited to maintenance only. The Supreme Court held that this would be satisfied by the original £50,000 awarded. Basically, the facts of this case merited an award of £50,000 and no more.

In our experience the standard of what would be reasonable is subjective. Each case turns on its own facts. However, the principle remains that a child can claim for reasonable financial provision but the value of their claim may be restricted.

See for further details. To discuss this or similar matters please do not hesitate to call our team or use the form on this page.


We're Social

Marc Yaffe is a Head of Business Development located in Manchesterin our Management BoardSports Law departments

View other posts by Marc Yaffe

Let us contact you


COVID-19 Update - Our website and phone lines are operating as normal and our teams are on hand to deal with all enquiries. Meetings can be conducted via telephone and video conferencing.

View our Privacy Policy

Areas of Interest