How to challenge an account freezing order

Call 0345 872 6666

‌
Hand placing a coin into a pink piggy bank, representing personal savings and financial security.

How to challenge an account freezing order

An account freezing order (AFO) is a court order used by the police and other authorities in England and Wales during the course of a civil investigation. It prevents you from accessing the funds in an account with a bank, building society or other financial institution, which means that you cannot withdraw, transfer or spend the money in the affected account.

These AFOs can be imposed without your knowledge, and prevent you from accessing the money you need for everyday commitments or running a business, without any ability to plan ahead. In the most serious circumstances, frozen assets can lead to a range of more difficult financial consequences.

Thankfully, there are ways to challenge an account freezing order without waiting for an investigation to end. If law enforcement agencies have frozen your bank account, you can often apply to have the AFO set aside or varied through the Magistrates’ Court. You can also request access to funds for essential expenditure, such as day-to-day living costs or business expenses.

At JMW, our business crime experts offer specialist advice on challenging an AFO, overcoming the restrictions imposed and restoring your access to your funds. In this blog post, we explain how AFOs work, how to establish why the account has been frozen, what options you may have to challenge the order and why proper advice and legal support make a significant difference to your prospect of success.

What is an account freezing order?

An account freezing order is a civil court order made under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, using powers introduced by the Criminal Finances Act 2017. It prevents payments or withdrawals from a bank, building society or other account, aside from certain exclusions as decided by the court.

AFO’s are typically sought by the police, HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC), the National Crime Agency and the Serious Fraud Office, although they may be used by other investigating authorities. These law enforcement agencies use account freezing orders when there are reasonable grounds to suspect that money is recoverable property, meaning property or funds obtained through unlawful conduct, or that are intended for use in unlawful conduct. However, an AFO can be made without criminal charges or a criminal conviction, and with a relatively low standard of proof.

A Magistrates’ Court can grant the order without advance notice where notification could risk dissipation of the funds in the bank account. Your account may therefore be frozen without warning using such orders, which can leave you unable to pay day-to-day living costs or operating expenses. As such, it is important to act quickly to challenge the order if you have the grounds to do so. This is not only a way to restore your access to certain funds, but an opportunity to start building a defence against the underlying investigation of which the AFO is only a part.

What should you do immediately if your bank account is frozen?

Your first step should be to seek legal advice if you learn that your account has been frozen. The team at JMW works quickly to minimise business disruption and vary or discharge the AFO at the earliest opportunity, and can also provide a wider defence during the course of the investigation. We will obtain the court order and any application papers, and check the key details (such as the relevant authority, amount, duration and permitted exclusions) to begin building your defence.

If you run a business, identify any urgent payments that are due to leave from the frozen account, such as wages or supplier payments. Keep key contacts in payroll and finance informed of urgent obligations, but do not try to move funds in breach of the freezing order.

Preserve bank statements, contracts and business records. Ask your solicitor to identify the authority's concerns before providing any documents or responses to the investigating authorities. At this stage, we will discuss whether there are grounds to challenge or vary the order, and begin the legal process on your behalf.

What are the grounds for challenging an account freezing order?

You can successfully challenge an account freezing order where the statutory requirements are not met, or where later evidence shows that restrictions should change. You can also apply for access to certain funds in many cases, including business operating costs, living expenses and, in some cases, legal expenses. Grounds on which we may challenge an account freezing order include:

Insufficient reasonable grounds for suspicion

The Magistrates’ Court must be satisfied that reasonable grounds exist for suspecting the relevant funds are recoverable property or intended for unlawful conduct. Suspicion is a lower threshold than proof of criminal activity, but it still requires an identifiable evidential basis.

Our account freezing order lawyers can assess whether the enforcement officer's material justifies freezing the particular money held and, if not, we can expose gaps or transactions taken out of context to support a challenge.

Evidence of a legitimate source of funds

You may show that deposits derive from employment, inheritance, property sales or ordinary business operations. By tracing the money from a legitimate source into the frozen account, including intermediate transfers where necessary, we can show that no money laundering or other financial crime took place.

Procedural errors or incomplete disclosure

Where an account freezing order was obtained without notice, we will examine what information was placed before the court. The applicant's obligation of full and frank disclosure may be relevant if significant facts were omitted or presented inaccurately. While a procedural error may not be enough to invalidate an order, it could support a challenge to the investigating authority's case.

Changed circumstances

New supporting evidence, completed enquiries or a material change in the investigation may justify reconsidering freezing orders. In some cases, showing that the investigation has failed to make material progress may be sufficient to have the order discharged or varied. We can also seek a narrower restriction if the continuing freeze covers legitimate funds that are not reasonably connected to the suspicion.

Varying the order

While this does not involve challenging the order directly, the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 allows the Magistrates’ Court to include exclusions when making an account freezing order, or to add them later. In some cases, you can request money for reasonable living expenses, including essential housing costs and ordinary living expenses, using evidence of regular outgoings and available resources.

An exclusion may also permit you to make the payments necessary to carry on a trade, profession or business. This includes payroll, suppliers or essential costs, where cash flow forecasts justify the payments you need to make.

Finally, you may apply for reasonable legal expenses relating to the relevant proceedings. The court must limit any permitted release to qualifying reasonable legal costs, specify the total amount and impose the applicable conditions. The account freezing order solicitors at JMW can advise you of whether you can secure an exclusion for legal fees or living expenses and work to secure the funds you need while we work to build your defence.

What evidence do you need to challenge an account freezing order?

The evidence you will need to challenge an AFO will depend on various factors, including the allegations that inform the underlying investigation and whether the order was implemented by the police, the National Crime Agency,HMRC or a different investigating authority. Account freezing orders may be tied to investigations into tax evasion, money laundering or other financial crimes, and the relevant evidence may also pertain to the underlying allegation.

Typically, our aim is to establish where the money came from, why it moved through the accounts and who owns it, and this relies on detailed evidence that may include:

  • Bank statements showing deposits, withdrawals and transfers across connected accounts.
  • Invoices, contracts, receipts and correspondence confirming commercial transactions.
  • Payslips, sale agreements, inheritance records and tax returns showing lawful receipts.
  • Management accounts, ledgers and other business records explaining turnover and payments.
  • Supporting evidence from accountants, counterparties or other people able to explain particular transactions.

For business accounts, we will work to reconcile unusual payment patterns - for example, if a third-party processor paid several customer receipts together, we will identify the statements and matching invoices to explain this pattern.

With this said, while a clear explanation for any questioned transactions is the best way to challenge an order or persuade the relevant authority that its suspicions no longer justify the freeze, it is not the only approach and our team can support you to pursue the best possible outcome.

How do you challenge an account freezing order in the Magistrates’ Court?

Anyone affected by an account freezing order can apply for its variation or discharge, including an account holder, their legal representative or an interested third party. The Magistrates’ Court can consider the application at any time while the order remains in force, which can be for up to two years from the date it was originally made, although it is best to act quickly to regain access to your funds at the earliest opportunity.

The steps to challenge an AFO and restore your access to the assets frozen by the court are as follows:

Step 1: Review the order and prepare your grounds

Your solicitor examines the original application, the suspected unlawful conduct and the evidence relied upon. We work to identify evidential gaps and determine whether to seek discharge or limited relief, based on the best possible outcome we believe is possible.

Step 2: Make a written application

The Magistrates’ Courts (Freezing and Forfeiture of Money in Bank and Building Society Accounts) Rules 2017 require an application to vary or set aside an order to be in writing and specify its grounds. If a court sent you notice, we will apply to that court with supporting evidence that addresses each contested issue. The court will arrange a hearing and notify the relevant parties.

Step 3: Prepare for the hearing

We will prepare the evidence we have gathered during the first stages of the process. Your solicitor may present financial documents, written representations and witness evidence during court proceedings, and witnesses who give oral evidence may be cross-examined. The investigating authority has an opportunity to respond, and affected third parties may also be heard, before the court makes a decision.

Step 4: The court's decision

The court may discharge the account freezing order, vary its terms or leave it in place, which means that your assets remain frozen. A variation might release identified frozen funds while allowing theinvestigation to continue, and does not mean that the legal process has concluded.

After the investigation, the relevant authority may agree that the funds should be released, seek to maintain the order within its permitted duration or pursue forfeiture to recover funds.

Step 5: Account forfeiture notices and account forfeiture orders

If the order remains in place, a senior officer representing the relevant authority may issue an account forfeiture notice proposing to forfeit all or some of the money. Account forfeiture orders do not require a criminal conviction. The notice specifies the sum, objection address and a period of at least 30 days, starting the following day, during which you can object.

Alternatively, the authority may apply to the Magistrates’ Court for an account forfeiture order. Forfeiture requires the court to determine whether money is recoverable property or intended for unlawful conduct. Account forfeiture orders can be contested with evidence of legitimate ownership and lawful sources.

Beyond this, a criminal investigation may continue separately and have serious consequences. It is best to work with an experienced solicitor to mount a defence from the outset of any investigation, and work towards the best possible outcome from the AFO and from any criminal proceedings.

Talk to us

JMW represents individuals, companies and directors facing account freezing orders, forfeiture applications and related financial crime investigations. Our expert solicitors will make representations to enforcement agencies and prepare applications to vary or set aside restrictions, or pursue exclusions for essential expenses.

If you need to challenge an AFO, contact JMW's account freezing order solicitors for urgent advice. Call 0345 872 6666 or use our online enquiry form to contact our legal team.

Did you find this post interesting? Share it on: