NHS spending billions on patients who don’t need hospital care
In recent years, the challenges facing the NHS have shifted from the theoretical to the starkly visible. Whether it is the queues of ambulances outside A&E or the long waits for elective surgery, the strain on the system is undeniable. However, a recent report has highlighted a particularly distressing aspect of this crisis: the "vicious cycle" of patients remaining in hospital beds long after they are medically fit to leave.
As a clinical negligence solicitor, my focus is always on patient safety. When we talk about the NHS "wasting billions", it is easy to get lost in the figures, but these billions represent more than just a budgetary shortfall; they represent a significant risk to the safety and well-being of thousands of patients.
The staggering cost of delayed hospital discharge
Recent data highlighted in the BBC’s news article suggests that the NHS spends approximately £2 billion a year on patients who are ready to go home but cannot. On any given day, thousands of hospital beds are occupied by individuals—often elderly or vulnerable—who no longer require acute medical care, but lack the necessary support to leave. This isn’t about "bed blocking" by choice. It is a systemic failure.
The primary drivers are well-known:
• Lack of social care: A shortage of care home beds or home-visit carers means patients cannot safely return to the community.
• Hospital processes: Delays in pharmacy (waiting for discharge medications) or administrative holdups in arranging transport.
• Rehabilitation gaps: A lack of community-based physiotherapy or occupational therapy to help patients regain their independence.
Why this is a patient safety issue
While the financial cost is a concern for the taxpayer, the human cost is a concern for all of us. A hospital is the best place to be when you are acutely unwell, but it is often not the case when you are recovering. From a patient safety perspective, "lingering" in a hospital bed carries three major risks:
• Hospital-acquired infections: The longer a patient stays in a clinical environment, the higher the risk of contracting infections like MRSA or C. diff. For a patient who is already weakened, these can have severe consequences.
• Deconditioning: Particularly for older patients, "pyjama paralysis" is a real threat. Just a few days of unnecessary bed rest can lead to a significant loss of muscle mass and mobility, making a return to independent living much harder.
• Mental wellbeing: The hospital environment is loud, bright, and disruptive. For patients with dementia, prolonged stays can lead to increased confusion, distress, and a decline in cognitive function.
Furthermore, every bed occupied by someone who shouldn’t be there, is a bed unavailable for someone who desperately needs it. This leads to "corridor care" and 12-hour A&E waits, situations where clinical staff are forced to treat patients in sub-optimal conditions, increasing the likelihood of errors.
Practical steps to navigate hospital discharge
If you have a loved one in hospital, the discharge process can feel overwhelming. While the NHS is guided by policies like the "Discharge to Assess" (D2A) model—which aims to move patients to a more appropriate setting as soon as they are stable—the reality can vary.
Here are some practical steps carers and family members can take to help ensure a safe and timely discharge:
• Ask about the estimated date of discharge: From the moment of admission, ask for the estimated date of discharge. This helps manage expectations and allows you to start planning for home care early.
• Request a discharge coordinator: Most hospitals have staff dedicated to managing the transition out of the ward. Identify who they are and keep regular open dialogue with them.
• Check the "Home First" options: Ask if there are community support teams (like "Rapid Response" or "Reablement") that can provide short-term care at home while longer-term arrangements are made.
• Be the patient’s advocate: Ensure the medical team knows exactly what the patient’s "baseline" was before they were admitted. If a patient lives alone and can no longer manage stairs, this needs to be flagged early to avoid a last-minute discharge crisis.
Moving forward
We often see headlines about the NHS needing more money, and while investment is critical, we must also ensure that the resources they have are used effectively. When billions are spent keeping people in the wrong environment, it can result in a lose-lose situation: the NHS loses money, and the patient loses their independence. Addressing the social care crisis is not just a political necessity; it is a clinical one. If we can improve the "flow" of patients out of hospitals, we naturally improve the safety of those waiting to get in.
As always, my advice to anyone navigating the healthcare system is to stay informed, ask questions, and never be afraid to advocate for the safest possible care.
There are time limits that apply to medical negligence compensation claims, so you should contact a solicitor at your earliest opportunity. At JMW, we have represented families who have not only suffered the most tragic of circumstances due to completely avoidable mistakes, but who also feel they were not listened to. If you believe there has been medical negligence, our expert team at JMW can offer support. Get in touch by calling 0345 872 6666 or use our online enquiry form to request a call back.
