You can contest a will due to dementia if there is evidence that the person who made the will lacked the mental capacity required to understand their decisions. A dementia diagnosis does not automatically make a will invalid and you will need strong evidence to prove that the person did not have sufficient testamentary capacity at the time they made the will.
Dementia is a progressive condition that can affect memory, understanding and decision-making ability in different ways. Its effects vary between individuals and can change over time, which means someone diagnosed with dementia may still have the mental ability required to make a valid will.
In this guide, JMW's Private Wealth Disputes team explains how dementia affects the validity of a will, the evidence needed to challenge it and the legal process for contesting a loved one's will on the grounds of lack of capacity.
At a glance: can you contest a will due to dementia?
A will can be challenged if dementia affected the person's testamentary capacity when they made it. The key points to understand are:
- Dementia does not automatically invalidate a will. A person diagnosed with dementia may still have sufficient mental capacity to make a legally valid will. The court considers whether the person understood their decisions when making the will, rather than relying on their diagnosis alone.
- The Banks v Goodfellow test applies. This establishes the legal requirements for testamentary capacity, which include that the testator must understand the nature of the will, the estate and potential beneficiaries.
- Medical and legal evidence is important. GP records, cognitive assessments, witness statements and the solicitor's file may establish whether the person had sufficient capacity.
- You can challenge a will before or after probate. However, acting early helps protect the estate and preserve relevant evidence.
- A successful challenge invalidates the will. The estate then passes under an earlier valid will or, if none exists, the rules of intestacy.
Can you contest a will if the person had dementia?
A will can be challenged if the person making it, known as the testator, lacked testamentary capacity when the will was created.
Testamentary capacity is the legal term for the mental ability required to make a valid will. A person must understand what making a will involves, have a sufficient understanding of their estate and recognise the people who might reasonably expect to benefit.
Being diagnosed with dementia does not necessarily mean these requirements were not met. Some people in the early stages of dementia retain sufficient mental capacity to make important decisions about their property and family.
The relevant consideration is whether the person had sufficient mental capacity when making their will, rather than their dementia diagnosis alone. However, evidence of their mental ability before and after making the will may also help establish whether they had the required capacity at the time.
If there is evidence that dementia prevented the testator from meeting the legal requirements, you may have grounds for contesting the validity of the will.
What mental capacity does someone need to make a will?
Testamentary capacity is the mental ability a person must have to make a legally valid will. In England and Wales, the principal legal test comes from the case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870).
The Banks v Goodfellow test establishes four requirements. The person making the will must:
- Understand the nature of making a will: Recognise that they are creating a legal document that determines what happens to their assets after death.
- Understand the extent of their estate: Have a general understanding of the property, money and other assets they are leaving behind.
- Recognise potential beneficiaries: Understand the claims of family members and other people who might reasonably expect to inherit.
- Be free from a disorder of the mind affecting their decisions: Not have a mental disorder or delusion that improperly influences how they distribute their estate.
The testator must have sufficient understanding to make meaningful decisions about how their property should be distributed, although they do not need to know every asset or the precise value of their estate.
For someone living with dementia, the question is whether their cognitive decline affected any of these requirements at the relevant time.
Does a dementia diagnosis mean someone lacks testamentary capacity?
A dementia diagnosis alone is not proof that someone lacked testamentary capacity when making their will.
Dementia can affect different aspects of a person's mental ability, including memory, reasoning, communication and their understanding of information. These effects do not necessarily prevent someone from making a valid will.
For example, a person may experience memory loss or need assistance with aspects of daily life but still understand the nature of a will, the extent of their property and the interests of their family.
Mental capacity is also specific to the decision being made. Someone may struggle with certain financial or personal decisions while retaining sufficient understanding to make a will.
The NHS guidance on mental capacity explains that a person's capacity can fluctuate and that an individual may be able to make some decisions but not others.
When considering a challenge to someone’s will, the court examines the evidence of the testator's capacity at the relevant time. Medical records, professional assessments and observations from people who knew them can all establish whether they understood their decisions.
What evidence is needed to contest a will due to dementia?
To challenge a will on the grounds of lack of testamentary capacity, you will need evidence showing how dementia affected the testator's understanding when they made the will.
Evidence commonly includes:
- Medical records: GP notes, hospital records, dementia assessments and information about the progression of the condition.
- Cognitive assessments: Tests carried out by healthcare professionals that provide insight into the person's memory, understanding and reasoning.
- The solicitor's file: Attendance notes and correspondence showing how the will was prepared and whether the solicitor considered the testator's capacity.
- Witness statements: Accounts from family members, carers, friends or professionals who observed the person's behaviour around the time the will was made.
- Previous wills: Earlier documents that explain changes in beneficiaries or the distribution of the estate.
- Expert medical evidence: An independent specialist's opinion on whether the testator had the necessary capacity at the relevant time.
No single piece of evidence necessarily determines whether a will is valid. A dementia diagnosis recorded in medical notes may be significant, but it must be considered alongside evidence of the person's actual understanding.
Our contentious probate solicitors assess the available evidence and identify what further information may be required to establish whether the testator lacked capacity.
What is a Larke v Nugus request?
A Larke v Nugus request is a formal request for information from the solicitor or other professional involved in preparing the deceased's will.
The request can seek details about the instructions given, the testator's apparent understanding and any concerns about their mental capacity.
The solicitor's file may contain notes of meetings, questions asked to establish capacity and information about who was present when instructions were provided.
This evidence can be particularly useful when investigating a will made after a dementia diagnosis.
What is the golden rule when making a will?
The golden rule is professional guidance recommending that, where an elderly person or someone with a serious illness makes a will, the solicitor should arrange for a medical practitioner to assess and record their testamentary capacity.
This provides contemporaneous evidence of the person's understanding and can help address future disputes.
However, the golden rule is not a statutory requirement. A will does not automatically become invalid because the solicitor did not arrange a medical assessment.
Similarly, following the golden rule does not guarantee that a will is valid. The court can still consider other evidence suggesting that the testator lacked testamentary capacity.
Where a person had dementia, records showing how their capacity was assessed may become important evidence in determining whether the will reflected their own informed decisions.
How do you contest a will due to dementia?
Contesting a will due to dementia involves establishing the legal grounds for the challenge, gathering evidence and taking appropriate steps to resolve the dispute.
The process will generally involve the following stages.
1. Establish your grounds for challenging the will
Our specialist solicitors will review the circumstances in which the will was made and assess whether there is a reasonable basis to argue that the testator lacked testamentary capacity.
We will also consider whether concerns about undue influence, lack of knowledge and approval or other legal grounds should be investigated separately.
2. Gather medical and legal evidence
Your solicitor will obtain relevant medical records, examine previous wills and seek information from the professional who prepared the contested document.
Depending on the circumstances, we may instruct independent medical experts to assess the available records and provide an opinion on the testator's capacity.
3. Consider protecting the estate
If probate has not yet been granted, it may be appropriate to enter a caveat at the Probate Registry. A caveat temporarily prevents a grant from being issued while the validity dispute is investigated.
This step is not appropriate for every inheritance dispute, so it is important to seek legal advice before taking action.
4. Contact the other parties
Once the evidence has been assessed, your solicitor can communicate with the executors, beneficiaries or other parties involved.
Many contentious probate disputes can be addressed through negotiation or alternative dispute resolution without requiring a full court hearing.
5. Begin court proceedings if necessary
If the parties cannot reach an agreement, the dispute may need to be determined by the court.
The court will consider the medical, documentary and witness evidence to determine whether the testator had sufficient mental capacity when making the will.
What happens if a will is found to be invalid due to dementia?
If the court finds that the testator lacked testamentary capacity, the contested will is declared invalid.
What happens to the deceased's estate will depend on whether an earlier valid will exists.
If there is a previous valid will, the estate must be distributed according to that document. If no valid will exists, the rules of intestacy will generally determine who inherits.
This means the outcome of a successful challenge differs depending on the deceased's previous arrangements and the family members entitled to inherit.
Is there a time limit for contesting a will due to dementia?
There is no general fixed statutory time limit specifically for challenging the validity of a will on the grounds of lack of testamentary capacity.
However, it is important to act promptly. If the estate has already been distributed, recovering assets may become more difficult.
Different time limits apply to other types of inheritance claims. For example, claims for reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 normally need to be brought within six months of the first grant of representation.
Seeking legal advice early allows you to identify the appropriate grounds for your claim and take steps to protect your position.
How JMW can help with contesting a will due to dementia
JMW's Private Wealth Disputes team advises beneficiaries, executors and family members on disputes involving testamentary capacity, dementia and the validity of wills.
We investigate concerns about the testator's mental ability, obtain relevant medical and legal records, and work with independent experts where further evidence is required.
Our solicitors also advise on related concerns involving undue influence, lack of knowledge and approval, and other circumstances that may affect whether a will is legally valid.
We take a sensitive, practical approach to family disputes, prioritising negotiation and mediation where possible while providing specialist representation in court proceedings when necessary.
Talk to us
If you believe a loved one lacked testamentary capacity when making their will, JMW’s Private Wealth Disputes solicitors will assess your circumstances and advise on the available legal options.
Call 0345 872 6666 or complete our online enquiry form to speak to a member of our team.
