How much does it cost to contest a will?

Call 0345 872 6666

‌
Older couple at a desk with a lawyer, who points to documents with a pen beside a calculator, notebooks and a laptop.

How much does it cost to contest a will?

The cost of contesting a will in England and Wales depends on the circumstances of your case, including the grounds for your claim, the evidence required and how the dispute is resolved. Many will disputes can be resolved through negotiation or mediation without the need for a full court hearing, which will keep legal costs down.

At JMW, our Private Wealth Disputes team will assess the likely costs from the outset and explain the funding options available to you, including no win, no fee arrangements in suitable cases. We will also advise on potential liability for the other party's legal costs, so you can make an informed decision about pursuing your claim.

In this guide, our team explains the costs involved in contesting a will, who is responsible for paying them and what you should consider before pursuing a claim.

At a glance: what costs are involved in contesting a will?

The costs of contesting a will can include several types of legal and professional fees.

Type of costWhat it covers
Solicitors' feesLegal advice, reviewing documents, gathering evidence, negotiations and preparing court proceedings
Barristers' feesSpecialist legal opinions, drafting court documents and representation at hearings
Court feesFees for issuing proceedings, making applications and attending certain hearings
Expert evidenceReports from medical professionals, handwriting specialists or other independent experts
Other parties' costsLegal costs you may be ordered to pay if your claim is unsuccessful or you act unreasonably

Not every will dispute involves all of these costs. Some claims can be resolved through correspondence or mediation, while others require substantial evidence and a full trial.

Our contentious probate solicitors assess the likely costs of your case at the outset and explain how these could change as the dispute progresses.

What affects the cost of contesting a will?

Several factors determine the legal costs of contesting a will. The most significant is the amount of work required to establish the legal position and resolve the dispute.

These factors include:

  • The grounds for contesting the will: Claims involving undue influence, fraud or lack of testamentary capacity require different investigations and types of evidence.
  • The evidence required: Obtaining medical records, witness statements or expert evidence increases the work involved, and there may be costs associated with certain documents.
  • The number of parties: Disputes involving multiple beneficiaries, executors or other interested parties typically involve additional correspondence and legal representation.
  • The complexity of the estate: Disagreements involving property, business interests or substantial assets require specialist valuations or further investigation.
  • The approach taken by the parties: Negotiation and alternative dispute resolution may resolve a claim without the additional costs of a contested trial.
  • Whether court proceedings are necessary: Preparing a case for court, attending hearings and obtaining specialist advocacy will affect the overall legal fees.

For example, challenging a will because the person making it lacked mental capacity requires medical evidence and an assessment of their circumstances when the will was signed. A claim involving a forged signature may instead require a handwriting expert, for which the costs will differ.

The stage at which the dispute concludes will also play a part. A case resolved through early negotiations generally involves less legal work than one proceeding to a final hearing.

When contesting a will, each party will normally pay their own legal costs as the case progresses. However, if the dispute reaches court, the judge has discretion to decide who should ultimately pay those costs.

Under Part 44 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party's legal costs. This is commonly described as the 'loser pays' principle, but it does not apply automatically in every case. The court has wide discretion and may consider:

  • Which party succeeded and whether they won on every issue
  • Whether either party acted unreasonably during the dispute
  • The conduct of the parties before and during court proceedings
  • Whether reasonable offers to resolve the dispute were rejected
  • Whether the parties engaged appropriately with mediation or other forms of alternative dispute resolution

Winning a case does not necessarily mean recovering all of your legal fees. The court may only allow recovery of costs it considers reasonable and proportionate.

There are also two established exceptions recognised in contentious probate cases. These concern circumstances where the testator's conduct, or the conduct of interested parties, caused the litigation, and cases where the circumstances reasonably justified investigating the will's validity.

Neither exception guarantees that the estate will pay the costs. The court considers the circumstances before making its decision.

Can the costs of contesting a will be paid from the estate?

The costs of contesting a will are not automatically paid from the deceased's estate.

Executors and personal representatives may be entitled to recover legal costs properly incurred when carrying out their duties. However, beneficiaries challenging a will do not have an automatic right to use estate assets to fund their claim.

Whether costs can be paid from the estate depends on the nature of the dispute, the parties' responsibilities and any court orders made.

Can you contest a will on a no win, no fee basis?

At JMW, we offer no win, no fee arrangements for contentious probate claims in suitable cases. Whether this funding option is available depends on the circumstances of your dispute, the strength of your claim and its potential value.

A no win, no fee arrangement is generally known as a conditional fee agreement (CFA). Under a conventional CFA, you will not have to pay your solicitor's fees covered by the agreement if your claim is unsuccessful.

Although no win, no fee arrangements can reduce the financial risks of bringing a claim, they do not necessarily cover every expense. Depending on the agreement, you may still be responsible for court fees, expert reports or the other party's legal costs if your claim is unsuccessful.

Other funding options include:

  • Private funding: Paying solicitors' fees at agreed hourly rates as the case progresses.
  • Deferred fee arrangements: Paying some or all legal fees at a later stage, where appropriate.
  • Legal expenses insurance: Using an existing insurance policy to cover eligible legal costs.

At JMW, we assess the available funding options alongside the merits of your case and explain the potential costs before you decide how to proceed.

Can you reduce the cost of contesting a will?

There are several practical steps that may help you to manage the costs of contesting a will without compromising your legal position.

Seeking expert legal advice early allows you to establish whether you have reasonable grounds for bringing a claim and what evidence will be needed.

Other steps include:

  1. Identify your legal grounds: Establish whether the dispute concerns the validity of the will, such as undue influence or testamentary capacity, or a separate claim for reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
  2. Preserve relevant evidence: Keep copies of wills, correspondence, financial records and other documents that may support your position.
  3. Consider negotiation: Direct negotiations allow the parties involved to reach an agreement without issuing court proceedings.
  4. Explore mediation: An independent mediator can help the parties to consider a mutually acceptable resolution.
  5. Review costs throughout the case: Understanding likely costs at each stage allows you to make an informed decision about continuing proceedings or accepting an offer.

A solicitor will also advise whether a proposed agreement adequately protects your interests and how rejecting an offer could affect your position on costs.

Is contesting a will worth the cost?

Whether contesting a will is worth pursuing depends on the legal grounds for your claim, the available evidence, the outcome you are seeking and the likely costs involved.

For example, someone excluded from a will may have reasonable grounds to challenge its validity where there is evidence of undue influence, fraud or lack of testamentary capacity. Alternatively, an eligible family member may have grounds to seek reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 without challenging the will's validity.

The value of the estate and the potential inheritance are also relevant, but a financial comparison alone does not determine whether a claim is worthwhile.

Our specialist solicitors assess the merits of your claim alongside the likely legal costs and available funding options, to help you decide on the most appropriate course of action.

How JMW can help with the costs of contesting a will

JMW's Private Wealth Disputes team advises beneficiaries, executors, trustees and other interested parties on bringing and defending will disputes.

We review the legal grounds, assess the evidence required and provide guidance on the likely costs of pursuing your case. Our solicitors also advise on funding arrangements, potential liability for other parties' costs and the financial implications of court proceedings.

Where possible, we pursue a resolution through negotiation or mediation. When court action is necessary, we provide specialist representation and consider the costs position throughout the proceedings.

We aim to help you protect your interests while making informed decisions about the costs and potential outcome of the dispute.

Talk to us

If you are considering contesting a will, our Private Wealth Disputes solicitors will explain your legal position, the likely costs and the funding options available.

For expert legal advice on bringing or defending a will dispute, call JMW on 0345 872 6666 or complete our online enquiry form to request a call back.

Did you find this post interesting? Share it on:

Related Posts