JMW client awarded summary judgment of over £300,000 against former accountant
Background
Associate solicitor Ben Blatch-Hanlon, assisted by JMW Partner Ben Johnson and trainee solicitors Jack McKee and Cameron Mackenzie-Price acted for an individual who made two loans to his former accountant on the basis it would be used to fund a new company and repaid to JMW’s client. The accountant ultimately failed to keep to the repayments, and JMW were instructed to seek to recover the loaned monies.
How did JMW help?
We acted for our client in issuing a High Court claim for the outstanding balance of the loans plus interest in the region of £550,000. The accountant defended the claim and alleged that the money initially advanced was not a loan but had always in fact been an investment, while admitting that the later advance was indeed a loan but had been repaid almost in full by the time the claim was issued. The initial advance being classed as an investment would have meant that the money would not be repayable to our client, not least as the accountant alleged the company had failed and so our client could not be repaid.
After issuing the claim, the parties ultimately settled their differences and the defendant accountant agreed to pay a substantial sum six-figure sum to JMW’s client. We were able to assist in negotiating the terms of the settlement, and drafted a robust settlement agreement and filed a Tomlin Order at court.
The terms of the settlement meant that the accountant was scheduled to pay the settlement sum in monthly instalments. The settlement agreement included an ‘acceleration clause’ pursuant to which the full balance of the agreed settlement sum would become immediately due and payable should the defendant fail to comply with his payment obligations, and which gave JMW’s client the right to apply to the court to lift the stay on proceedings and be granted summary judgment in such circumstances.
The defendant accountant almost immediately breached the terms of the settlement, failing to make payments of the instalments on time despite multiple reminders. Ultimately JMW’s client lost patience and applied for summary judgment for the full balance of the settlement sum, which at the point of the application being made stood at over £300,000.
What did the court decide?
Following the issuing of the application but prior to the hearing, the defendant entered into a ‘breathing space moratorium’ which meant that enforcement action could not be taken for a period of 2 months in order to allow him time to try and manage his debts.
At the hearing, the judge had to deal with the issues of:
a. whether the acceleration clause did in fact allow JMW’s client to lift the stay and make the application;
b. if the application for summary judgment should be granted, including if the judge had any discretion in this regard; and
c. whether the breathing space moratorium included the granting of a court judgment.
Ultimately, the judge held in JMW’s client’s favour, granting the application for summary judgment, which he held was correctly issued, and that he did not have discretion due to the wording of the settlement agreement. The breathing space moratorium did not prevent the granting of summary judgment as the application was made prior to commencement of the moratorium, although it did mean that enforcement of the judgment could not take place until the moratorium had expired.
Ben Blatch-Hanlon, who acted for the client throughout the proceedings, said: “I was pleased with the outcome that was achieved for our client, who had been very patient. When it was evident that the accountant was not going to repay the monies loaned, we were able to rely on the terms of the settlement agreement that JMW drafted, which ensured that our client was entitled to summary judgment in the event of a breach of the terms of settlement by the defendant. The judge’s comments in granting judgment in our client’s favour highlighted the importance of a well-drafted settlement agreement which ensures that the party receiving payment is able to take necessary steps to enforce any breaches of the settlement terms.”
