Maternity Negligence Claims

Maternity negligence claims arise where medical negligence during pregnancy, labour, delivery, or postnatal care causes avoidable harm to a woman, her baby, or both. Maternity care involves multiple healthcare professionals, including midwives, doctors and obstetric teams, all of whom owe a clear duty of care. When that duty is breached through negligent treatment, poor clinical decision-making, or inadequate monitoring, the consequences can be serious and life-altering.

JMW advises women and families affected by maternity medical negligence across all stages of maternity care. Our medical negligence team acts in claims involving pregnancy negligence, labour and delivery negligence, and failures in postnatal care. We can support you in cases where negligent maternity care has resulted in birth injuries, birth trauma, psychological trauma, or long-term physical injury to the mother or baby.

Our maternity negligence solicitors will investigate your medical negligence claim thoroughly. We provide clear advice on the strength of a medical negligence claim, the claims process, and how compensation is assessed, while handling every case with sensitivity and care.

If you believe negligent maternity care has affected you or your baby, JMW provides confidential advice on making a maternity negligence claim. Speak to our medical negligence team on 0345 872 6666, or fill in our online contact form to request a call back at your convenience.

How JMW Can Help

JMW supports women and families who believe negligent maternity care has caused avoidable harm during pregnancy, labour, delivery, or postnatal treatment. Our medical negligence solicitors advise on maternity negligence claims involving hospitals, birth centres, and other NHS maternity services, as well as care provided by other healthcare providers.

Our medical negligence team has extensive experience investigating complex maternity negligence cases, including pregnancy negligence, labour and delivery negligence, and failures in postnatal care. We act where negligent treatment, inadequate monitoring, or failures by medical professionals have led to birth injuries, psychological trauma, or long-term physical harm, including injuries affecting the mother.

From the outset, JMW investigates maternity negligence claims thoroughly. We obtain and review relevant medical records, instruct independent medical experts, and assess whether the healthcare professionals involved breached their duty of care and caused avoidable harm. This careful approach allows us to advise clearly on the strength of a medical negligence claim and the options available.

We understand that a maternity or pregnancy negligence claim often involves deeply distressing experiences and can have lasting psychological and practical consequences. JMW provides clear, compassionate advice throughout the claims process, keeping you informed at every stage and explaining complex issues in straightforward terms.

Our medical negligence team is led by the highly experienced Eddie Jones and Angharad Hughes, and includes members of the Law Society’s specialist panel of clinical negligence solicitors and the Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA) solicitors panel. This specialist expertise supports our work on maternity medical negligence claims, including cases involving birth centres, midwife negligence, and failures to escalate care appropriately.

If you have concerns about the maternity care you received, JMW’s medical negligence solicitors provide confidential advice on making a maternity negligence claim and can explain the next steps without obligation.

Meet the Team

JMW’s maternity negligence claims are handled by specialist medical negligence solicitors with extensive experience advising women and families affected by negligent maternity care. Our team understands the medical, legal, and personal issues involved in maternity negligence cases and approaches every claim with care, sensitivity and attention to detail.

What Is Maternity Negligence?

Maternity care amounts to negligence when a healthcare provider fails to meet the standard of care expected of a reasonably competent medical professional in the same circumstances, and that failure causes avoidable harm. In maternity negligence claims, liability is assessed by examining whether the care provided during pregnancy, labour, delivery, or postnatal treatment fell below accepted clinical standards and whether that failing made a material difference to the outcome for the mother or baby.

Establishing maternity negligence involves two key questions:

• Whether the healthcare professional or maternity team breached their duty of care through negligent treatment, delayed decision-making, or a failure to act when concerns should reasonably have been identified.
• Whether that breach directly resulted in avoidable injury, deterioration in health, or psychological trauma that would not otherwise have occurred.

Maternity negligence claims often involve reviewing how decisions were made in real time, including how risks were assessed, how observations were recorded, and whether concerns were escalated appropriately. Liability may arise where medical professionals failed to follow established clinical guidance, did not seek senior input when required, or did not arrange timely access to appropriate medical treatment.

Negligence can occur in any maternity setting, including hospitals, birth centres and community care. The standard applied does not change depending on location. Where the care provided falls below acceptable standards and causes avoidable harm, a maternity medical negligence claim may arise.

What Are the Most Common Causes of Maternity Negligence?

Maternity negligence claims often arise where developing risks during pregnancy, labour, or birth were identifiable but not acted on appropriately. Common causes include:

• Inadequate monitoring: failures to record, interpret, or respond to maternal observations or fetal heart rate monitoring during pregnancy or labour.
• Delayed escalation of concerns: where midwives or other medical staff do not seek timely obstetric input or senior clinical review when complications arise.
• Delays in transfer of care: including failure to arrange prompt transfer from a birth centre to an obstetric-led unit when risk factors or complications develop.
• Poor management of known conditions: such as pre-eclampsia or gestational diabetes, where care plans are not adjusted or deterioration is not addressed appropriately.
• Errors during labour and delivery: including delayed intervention when labour is not progressing safely, inappropriate decision-making during assisted delivery, or failure to act when urgent intervention is required.
• Negligent postnatal care: failures to investigate symptoms after birth, delayed diagnosis of complications, or inadequate treatment during the postnatal period.

Where these issues result in avoidable harm to the mother or baby, they may form the basis of a maternity negligence claim.

Making a Negligence Claim Against a Birth Centre

Birth centres are designed to support women with low-risk pregnancies, through midwife-led care in a non-medical environment. While many women have positive experiences, maternity negligence can arise where healthcare professionals in a birth centre do not respond appropriately when circumstances change or complications develop.

Negligence involving birth centres often relates to failures in recognising risk or acting on emerging concerns. This can include situations where a healthcare professional, fails to identify warning signs during labour, underestimates the seriousness of a woman’s condition, or does not escalate concerns in line with clinical guidance. In these circumstances, delays in decision-making can lead to avoidable harm.

A common issue in birth centre maternity negligence cases is delayed transfer to obstetric-led care. Where labour is not progressing safely, maternal observations deteriorate, or fetal monitoring raises concerns, prompt transfer to hospital is required. Failures to arrange timely ambulance transfer, delays in seeking senior input, or poor communication between maternity services can all contribute to negligent care.

Although birth centres are often described as lower-intervention settings, the duty of care owed to the mother and baby remains the same. Midwives and other healthcare professionals must act within their competence, follow escalation protocols, and arrange access to appropriate medical treatment when needed. Where these standards are not met and avoidable harm occurs, this may give rise to a maternity negligence claim.

What Is the Maternity Negligence Compensation Claims Process?

Maternity negligence claims follow a structured legal process to determine whether negligent maternity care caused avoidable harm and who is legally responsible. The process usually involves the following stages:

• Initial review of the care provided: a detailed discussion of what happened during pregnancy, labour, delivery, or postnatal care, including care provided by hospitals, birth centres, and other healthcare providers.
• Obtaining medical records: relevant medical records are requested and reviewed, including maternity notes, monitoring records, and postnatal documentation.
• Independent medical assessment: independent medical experts assess whether the medical professionals involved breached their duty of care and whether that breach caused avoidable harm.
• Formal claim preparation: where the evidence supports a claim, a clinical negligence claim is prepared setting out the allegations of negligent treatment and the injuries suffered.
• Response from the healthcare provider: the NHS trust or other healthcare provider responds, either admitting or disputing liability.
• Next steps: where liability is admitted, the focus moves to assessing compensation. Where liability is disputed, further evidence and legal steps may be required.

Throughout the process, JMW will manage the legal work, explain each stage clearly, and keep you informed so you can understand how your maternity negligence claim is progressing.

Learn more by reading our guide to the medical negligence claims process.

Q

How much compensation can I claim for maternity negligence?

A

Compensation in maternity negligence claims is assessed by considering how negligent maternity care has affected the mother, the baby, or both. The purpose of compensation is to reflect the harm caused and the financial consequences arising from that harm, rather than to punish the healthcare provider.

When assessing a maternity negligence compensation claim, the following factors are typically considered:

• The nature of the injuries: including physical injuries, birth injuries, brain injuries, or psychological trauma resulting from negligent treatment.
• Severity and long-term impact: whether the injuries are temporary or permanent, and how they affect daily life, independence, relationships, and future health.
• Psychological injury: compensation may take account of recognised psychological trauma, including the impact of a traumatic birth experience or postnatal mental health conditions linked to negligent care.
• Financial losses and expenses: this can include medical costs, ongoing treatment needs, therapy, care requirements, and other reasonable expenses linked to the harm caused.
• Future needs: where maternity negligence has resulted in life-altering injuries or long-term disability, compensation may reflect future care, support, and medical requirements.

Each medical negligence case is assessed on its own facts, and compensation depends on the specific injuries, losses, and long-term impact involved. JMW provides clear advice on how compensation is assessed once the medical evidence has been reviewed.

Q

What evidence is needed to support a maternity negligence claim?

A

Evidence plays a central role in maternity negligence claims, as it is used to assess whether the care provided fell below an acceptable standard and whether that failure caused avoidable harm. JMW assists in identifying, obtaining and reviewing the evidence needed to support a medical negligence claim.

The key types of evidence in maternity negligence cases typically include:

• Medical records: relevant medical records from pregnancy, labour, delivery and postnatal care, including maternity notes, monitoring charts and discharge summaries.
• Medical reports: reports prepared by independent medical experts who assess whether medical professionals breached their duty of care and caused avoidable harm.
• Independent medical assessment: specialist assessment by an independent medical expert, often in obstetrics, midwifery, neonatology, or another relevant field.
• Evidence of injury and impact: records showing the physical or psychological effects of negligent maternity care, including details of treatment received and ongoing medical needs.
• Financial evidence: documentation relating to medical expenses, care costs, and other financial losses linked to the injuries suffered.

In most cases, JMW obtains the relevant medical records and expert evidence on behalf of clients. This allows your medical negligence compensation claim to be assessed thoroughly and objectively, without you needing to gather complex medical information yourself.

Learn more by reading our guide explaining how to make a medical negligence claim.

Q

What are the time limits for bringing a maternity negligence claim?

A

Maternity negligence claims are subject to legal time limits, known as limitation periods. In most cases involving maternity medical negligence, a claim must be started within three years of the date the negligence occurred or from the date when it first became reasonably clear that avoidable harm had been caused by negligent maternity care.

In some situations, the three-year time limit may begin later. This can apply where the effects of negligent treatment were not immediately apparent, or where the connection between the care provided and the harm suffered only became clear at a later stage. Each maternity negligence case is assessed on its own facts to determine when the limitation period applies.

Time limits can differ when a claim relates to a birth injury claim. For cases where a baby has been injured, the three-year limitation period usually does not begin until the child reaches the age of 18. As such, claims involving severe or life-altering injuries, such as brain injuries, may still be brought many years after the birth.

Because limitation rules can be complex, early legal advice can clarify how much time is available to make a maternity negligence claim. JMW will advise you on time limits as part of the initial assessment, allowing informed decisions to be made without unnecessary delay.

You can learn more by reading our guide to time limits for medical negligence cases.

Q

How long does a maternity negligence claim take?

A

The length of time it takes to make a maternity negligence claim will vary depending on the circumstances of the case, the complexity of the medical issues involved, and how the healthcare provider responds. Some claims can progress more quickly, while others take longer to investigate fully.

Factors that can affect how long a maternity negligence claim takes include:

• The complexity of the medical issues: claims involving labour and delivery negligence, birth injuries, or brain injuries often require detailed review by multiple independent medical experts.
• Availability of medical records: delays can occur while relevant medical records are obtained from hospitals, birth centres, or other healthcare providers.
• Independent medical assessment: expert review is essential in medical negligence cases and can take time, particularly where specialist input is required.
• Acceptance of liability: if the healthcare provider admits responsibility early, the claim may progress more quickly. Where liability is disputed, further evidence and legal steps may be needed.
• The extent of ongoing treatment or recovery: in some cases, it may be appropriate to wait until the long-term impact of the injuries is clearer before the claim is concluded.

Speak to JMW, and we will keep you informed throughout the process and explain what is happening at each stage.