- Solicitors For Business
- Solicitors For You
- About Us
- News & Events
Case Study: Perforated Bowel Following Procedure Leads to Fatality
Linda, 35 years old, York
This case study outlines how we acquired a £275,000 settlement for a family after their mother was left with perforated bowel after surgery, tragically resulting in her death.
If you are looking for information on how JMW can help you to make a claim yourself you can go directly to our obstetrics and gynaecology negligence claims page here.
Linda was born with a congenital cranio-facial abnormality known as Pierre Robins Syndrome (PRS). She had experienced three previous pregnancies with no problems and when she became pregnant for a fourth time, she was booked for antenatal care at her local general hospital. When it was suspected that the baby was affected by PRS, Linda was transferred to a teaching hospital, where the diagnosis was confirmed.
Caesarean and the insertion of a Redivac drain
Linda gave birth at the teaching hospital, by elective caesarean section with ex-utero intrapartum treatment (EXIT). This is a method of maintaining the utero-placental circulation during the caesarean section to establish an airway to the baby prior to full delivery.
A Redivac drain was inserted into her abdomen in view of the risk of bleeding following the procedure. The day after the operation, it was noted that Linda had a swollen but soft abdomen. But, as there was no vomiting and she felt hungry, it was agreed that the Redivac drain could be removed.
Redivac drain removal
Following removal of the drain, Linda became increasingly distressed with abdominal pain and swelling. It is likely that a perforation to Linda’s caecum had occurred when the Redivac drain was removed, due to the midwife failing to adequately discontinue suction from the drain prior to the procedure.
An abdominal X-ray was performed and a bowel obstruction suspected. Linda was reviewed by a surgical doctor and the diagnosis was post-operative ileus (slowing down of normal bowel activity), rather than anything more serious.
The symptoms continued for a week, although she noted feeling better and began to eat and mobilise. However, she had a persistently increased heart rate, an elevated white cell count, a reduced serum albumin, abdominal distension and oedema of the abdominal wall and legs with subsequent blistering.
Perforation of the bowel
Almost two weeks after giving birth, Linda complained of sudden onset of acute abdominal pain and was found to have a clinical picture consistent with sepsis.
A CT scan suggested the presence of ascites and air in the peritoneal cavity - almost certainly due to a perforation of the bowel. Linda underwent emergency laparotomy and was found to have generalised peritonitis, with two litres of free pus and fluid. She developed acute respiratory multi-organ failure and died a week later.
Lack of surgical intervention
JMW Solicitors alleged that had Linda been provided with an appropriate standard of care, she would have undergone early laparotomy, and would not have developed generalised peritonitis. Surgical intervention at any point up until her sudden deterioration would, in all probability, have saved her life.
Linda was survived by her four children. Unfortunately, due to her extensive disabilities, the daughter born with PRS died before the conclusion of the claim. The hospital admitted causation - namely that but for that negligence, the deceased would have survived - and the claim was settled for £275,000.
More Case Studies
Christine had 3 children all of whom were delivered by forceps. This resulted in a number of gynaecological problems. She underwent a posterior vaginal repair, a colposuspension and eventually had an abdominal hysterectomy.
Jane noticed a lump in her vagina which was not painful. Her gynaecologist diagnosed a urethral cyst but due to the proximity to the bladder he referred her on to a consultant urologist for treatment.
Kayleigh delivered her first baby by caesarean section, the baby was well and Kayleigh was looking forward to going home. However, Kayleigh became gravely ill with HELLP syndrome and was admitted to the intensive care unit.
Lucy was pregnant with her first baby and attended hospital to be induced.. There were difficulties progressing labour and she required an episiotomy.
Rita was injured when forceps were used negligently as she gave birth to her child. The resulting injuries, both physical and psychological, resulted in an award of compensation of £80,000.
When Felicity was 15½ weeks pregnant she underwent a scan at hospital and she was told the baby did not have a heart beat and was only 12½ weeks in size
After complaining of vaginal bleeding Mrs Smith, a fit 71 year old, underwent a hysteroscopy to remove a uterine polyp. She had previously had a number of similar polyps successfully removed by D&C (Dilation and curettage)
Case study of a new mother who was awarded £200,000 in compensation due to substandard care during labour.
Bryony Doyle, a specialist medical negligence solicitor at JMW, secured £70,000 in compensation for a woman who was left with urinary incontinence and the need for further surgery after a negligently performed hysterectomy.