Private FDRs Advice
A private financial dispute resolution (FDR) hearing can help you resolve financial issues in divorce more quickly, privately and strategically than waiting for the standard court process to unfold. It gives both parties the opportunity to receive a clear, independent view from a private FDR judge, then use that indication to negotiate a settlement.
At JMW, we advise clients before, during and after a private FDR hearing. We help you decide whether a private financial dispute resolution hearing is the right route for you, prepare your financial disclosure, select the right private FDR judge and approach the hearing with a clear settlement strategy.
Private FDRs are particularly useful in financial proceedings involving complex assets, business interests, pensions, trusts, property portfolios or international wealth. They can also be effective where both parties want to avoid delay, keep momentum in negotiations and reduce the risk of a final hearing.
Our family law team provides focused, practical advice at every stage. We work with you to protect your position, narrow the issues in dispute and prepare for the private FDR in a way that gives settlement the best possible chance.
To speak to our family law team in confidence, call 0345 872 6666 or complete our online enquiry form to arrange a call at a time that suits you.
On This Page
What Our Clients Say
How JMW Can Help
A private FDR works best when full and frank financial disclosure has been exchanged, when settlement discussions are appropriate and the matter has been carefully prepared. The hearing itself is important, but the strategy, disclosure and negotiation work that takes place beforehand will often determine whether the parties reach settlement.
At JMW, we provide clear, structured advice throughout the private FDR process. We help you understand whether a private FDR is the right route, how your case should be presented and what a realistic outcome may look like before you enter the hearing.
We advise on:
- Whether a private FDR is suitable for your financial proceedings
- Choosing the right private FDR judge for the issues in dispute
- Preparing Form E and other financial disclosure
- Reviewing your spouse’s financial disclosure and identifying any gaps
- Narrowing the main points of dispute before the hearing
- Preparing without prejudice offers
- Preparing the agreed bundle and position statement
- Working with a barrister where this will strengthen your case
- Representing you at the private FDR hearing
- Negotiating settlement on the day and afterwards
- Preparing a consent order if an agreement is reached
Private FDRs are often used in family finance cases where there is a need for focused specialist input. This may include cases involving business interests, complex pensions, inherited wealth, trusts, investment portfolios, private school fees, international assets or differing views about future income and housing needs.
JMW advises on both private FDRs and court-based financial dispute resolution, so we will help you compare the options and decide which route is most likely to move your case forward cost effectively.
Our family law team has more than 40 specialist family lawyers across Manchester, Liverpool and London. We act for clients nationally and internationally, including high net worth individuals, business owners, professionals and families with complex financial arrangements. JMW’s family team is recognised by the Legal 500, Chambers & Partners and Spear’s 500 for its work in high net worth divorce, cross-border disputes and complex cases involving business assets, pensions and property.
We also work closely with leading barristers and financial remedy specialists, and we can identify the right financial remedy specialist to act as the private FDR judge in your case. Where counsel is needed for advocacy or specialist input, we coordinate that support as part of a joined-up strategy.
Meet the Team
Our family law team advises on private FDRs and complex financial proceedings, enabling clients to prepare strategically, negotiate effectively and work towards a fair financial settlement.
What Is a Private FDR?
A private FDR is a voluntary hearing used to help parties resolve financial proceedings without waiting for the standard court process to reach a court FDR. This is a form of non-court dispute resolution, and allows both parties to understand the likely outcome if the case were to continue to a final hearing.
The parties jointly appoint a private FDR judge, usually a financial remedy specialist such as a senior barrister or retired judge. The private FDR judge reviews the financial disclosure, considers each party’s position and gives an impartial indication of how the dispute may be viewed by a court.
This indication is not binding. A private FDR is a without prejudice hearing, so discussions are focused on settlement and cannot usually be referred to openly if the case later proceeds to a final hearing. This gives both parties space to negotiate with a clear understanding of risk, while maintaining confidentiality around offers.
The process is based on a simple concept: the parties pay for a specialist evaluator to help unlock settlement. By choosing the right private FDR judge and setting aside proper time for negotiation, many cases make meaningful progress whilst avoiding some of the delay and essential uncertainty of litigation and court proceedings.
A private FDR can take place within existing court proceedings, or before a formal court application is made if both parties agree and there has been sufficient financial disclosure. The goal is the same: to help the parties reach a fair financial settlement before the cost and pressure of a final hearing.
Private FDR vs In-Court FDR
An in-court FDR and a private FDR have the same overall purpose. Both help parties resolve financial matters by receiving an indication from a judge and then negotiating settlement. The difference is the level of control the parties have.
At an in-court FDR, the hearing is listed by the court and the judge is allocated through the court system. This can work well, but the parties depend on court listing availability and the judge may have limited time to prepare or assist with negotiations on the day.
With a private FDR, the parties choose the private FDR judge and arrange the hearing at a time convenient to the parties. The private FDR takes place outside the court, usually in solicitors offices or barristers chambers, and a full day is typically set aside to maximise the opportunity for settlement.
| In-Court FDR | Private FDR | |
|---|---|---|
| Judge | Allocated by the court | Chosen by the parties |
| Expertise | Depends on availability | Parties can appoint a financial remedy specialist |
| Timing | Depends on court listing | Arranged at a time convenient to the parties |
| Venue | Takesplace at court | Usually in solicitors offices or barristers chambers |
| Time available | Often limited by the court list | Usually a full day is set aside for negotiation |
| Cost | No private judge fee | Parties pay the private FDR judge, usually shared |
| Control | More dependent on the court process | More flexible and tailored |
A court-based FDR can still be effective, particularly where the issues are straightforward or the court timetable is moving efficiently. However, a private FDR can offer a more focused route where timing, privacy, specialist input or control over the process is important.
For clients with complex financial arrangements, choosing an experienced FDR judge can be a significant advantage. The right private FDR judge can give a clear view on the likely outcome and help the parties focus on the issues most likely to determine settlement.
Private FDR vs Early Neutral Evaluation
A private FDR is a form of early neutral evaluation, but the two terms are not always interchangeable. Early neutral evaluation is a broader process where an independent specialist gives a non-binding view on the likely outcome of a dispute. It can be used in different types of family law and civil disputes.
A private FDR is more specific. It is used in divorce and family finance cases and is structured around the financial dispute resolution process. The private FDR judge considers the financial disclosure exchanged by the parties, as well as position statements, the agreed bundle and any offers for settlement that the parties have made, before giving an indication designed to help the parties negotiate an agreement.
In both private FDR and early neutral evaluation, the evaluator does not impose an outcome. Their role is to help the parties understand the strengths, risks and likely outcome of their positions. This makes the process different from the arbitration process, where an arbitrator can make a binding decision.
Private FDRs sit within the wider landscape of non-court dispute resolution, alongside mediation, collaborative law, arbitration and early neutral evaluation. The right option will depend on the issues in dispute, the level of disclosure available and whether the parties need facilitation, evaluation or a binding decision.
How the Private FDR Process Works
A private FDR works best once both parties have exchanged disclosure and the key financial issues are clear. The process is flexible, but most private FDR hearings follow three stages: preparation before the hearing, the hearing itself and the steps taken afterwards.
Before the hearing
Both parties usually exchange financial disclosure using Form E. Depending on the case, further information may be needed, such as replies to questionnaires, business valuations, pension reports, property valuations or updated income evidence.
Preparation also includes narrowing the points in dispute, making without prejudice offers on settlement, preparing an agreed bundle and exchanging position statements. This ensures the private FDR judge has the information needed to give a meaningful indication.
On the day
The private FDR takes place outside of court, usually in solicitors offices or barristers chambers, with a full day set aside to maximise the opportunity for negotiation.
Each side presents its position to the private FDR judge. The judge then gives an indication of the likely outcome if the case were to continue to a final hearing. The parties’ representatives then use that indication to negotiate, often in separate rooms, with the aim of reaching settlement.
After the hearing
If the parties reach settlement, the agreement can be recorded and converted into a consent order for approval by the court. Once approved by the court, the consent order becomes legally binding.
If settlement is not reached, negotiations can continue after the hearing. The case may proceed through the court process towards a final hearing, or the parties may consider another form of alternative dispute resolution, including arbitration.
How Much Does a Private FDR Cost?
The cost of a private FDR will depend on the seniority of the private FDR judge, the complexity of the financial issues, the amount of preparation required and whether barristers are instructed. A private FDR judge may be a senior barrister, solicitor, barrister or retired judge with an additional qualification or specialist experience in financial remedy cases.
The parties usually share the private FDR judge’s fee. There will also be legal fees associated with preparing for and attending the private FDR hearing.
Although a private FDR involves additional costs, it can be cost effective where it helps the parties reach settlement earlier. In many cases, the cost of a focused private FDR is outweighed by avoiding further litigation and court proceedings, reducing delay and limiting the risk of the matter continuing to a final hearing.
We will give you clear advice on likely costs before the private FDR process begins, including what preparation is needed and whether instructing a barrister is likely to add value in your case.
Is a Private FDR Right for Your Case?
A private FDR can be a strong option where both parties want a structured, settlement-focused route through financial proceedings. It is often particularly effective where the issues are highly complex, or where the parties would benefit from a private FDR judge with specific experience in the assets or financial arrangements involved.
A private FDR may be suitable where:
- Both parties have exchanged disclosure
- The main points of dispute are clear enough for a meaningful indication
- Court listing delays are affecting progress
- Privacy and control over the process are important
- The case involves complex or high-value assets
- Both parties are legally represented and ready to negotiate
A private FDR may be less suitable where one party has not provided proper financial disclosure, urgent court orders are needed, or one party is not willing to engage constructively. In those situations, a court based route or another form of alternative dispute resolution may be more appropriate.
The right option will depend on the stage of the case, the financial information available and the approach of both parties. We can advise whether private FDR, court FDR, mediation, arbitration or another route is most likely to help you reach a settlement cost effectively.
FAQs About Private FDRs
- How long does a private FDR take?
A private FDR hearing usually takes one full day. Preparation takes place in the weeks beforehand, including financial disclosure, Form E, an agreed bundle, position statements and without prejudice offers.
Because a private FDR is arranged outside the usual court listing process, it can often take place sooner than an in-court FDR.
- Is a private FDR legally binding?
A private FDR is not legally binding in itself. The private FDR judge gives an indication of the likely outcome, but they do not impose a decision on the parties.
If the parties reach settlement, the agreement can be recorded in a consent order and sent to the court for approval. Once approved by the court, the consent order becomes legally binding.
- Do I need a barrister for an FDR hearing?
Not always. Some cases can be managed by solicitors alone, but many clients choose to instruct a barrister for a private FDR hearing, particularly where the case involves complex financial disclosure, business interests, pensions, trusts or high-value assets.
We can advise whether instructing a barrister is likely to strengthen your position and help you prepare effectively for the hearing.
- What happens if we do not settle at the private FDR?
If the parties do not reach settlement at the private FDR, negotiations can continue afterwards. The indication given by the FDR judge can still help narrow the issues and guide further offers.
If agreement remains out of reach, the case may continue towards a final hearing, where the court will make a binding decision. Some parties may also consider mediation, arbitration or another form of alternative dispute resolution.
- What are the disadvantages of a private FDR?
The main disadvantage is the additional cost, because the parties pay the private FDR judge’s fee as well as their own legal costs. A private FDR also requires both parties to engage constructively and provide proper financial disclosure.
Where the process is well prepared, those additional costs can be outweighed by the opportunity to avoid delay, reduce litigation and court proceedings and reach settlement before a final hearing.
Talk to Us
If you are considering a private FDR, or want advice on the best way to resolve financial matters in divorce, our family law team can help you understand your options and prepare strategically.
We advise clients at every stage of financial proceedings, from early negotiation and financial disclosure through to private FDRs, court FDRs, consent orders and final hearing preparation. Our focus is on helping you protect your position, reduce unnecessary delay and work towards a fair financial settlement.
To speak to our family law team in confidence, call 0345 872 6666 or complete our online enquiry form to arrange a consultation at a time that suits you.
